How to Serve Falk’s Audience Identity Types

It feels like I’ve only just started this project, but I’ve already put around 50 hours into it. What’s becoming clear to me is that it’s nearly impossible to neatly categorize human beings as museum visitors. Some fit one identity type pretty strongly, but their motivations may change on the next visit. For example, a woman may visit alone to relax while her kids are at school but come as a facilitator on Second Saturday to teach them about what she saw on her last solo visit. Likewise, an experience-seeker may fall in love at first sight with the Romantic-era landscapes on the upper floor and continue to visit to study them and see new exhibitions, transforming into an explorer.

After the initial wave of guest interceptions and digesting the data gathered, it’s apparent that a large percentage of the museum’s guests are either explorers, facilitators, or rechargers. 128 adults and 28 visitors under the age of 18 responded to the survey I drafted, and most of them expressed motivations that strongly correlated with one or two of Falk’s identity types. Check out the results so far:

IdentitiesPercentageScreenshot

Very few visitors fit into the identities of experience-seeker or professional/hobbyist; however, many explorers, rechargers, and facilitators expressed their primary identity with secondary traits of the professional/hobbyist or experience-seeker motivation. Visitors like the couple who came to Philbrook to reminisce over their engagement in the gardens a few years ago fit this description. One came to relax, a definite recharger, and the other came to explore and learn. The explorer identified herself as a hobby artist and a lover of Impressionism, so she liked to see the Impressionist paintings and remembered the Monet exhibition very well. Explorer is her primary identity, but she expresses a strong interest in seeing things that relate to her hobby, which means that her secondary identity is a professional/hobbyist.

It’s extremely valuable to have information about guest identities and motivations. The Bernsen Director of Education and Public Programs told me that my data has already become useful in their endeavor to develop books about the gardens at Philbrook. Knowing that we have few professional/hobbyist identities visiting for the gardens but plenty of rechargers visiting to stroll there, one can assume that a coffee table book for leisurely reading is more likely to fly off of shelves than an informational, scientifically labeled book about the plants, trees, flowers, growing seasons, and organization of the gardens.

cropped-cropped-download.png

What Philbrook needs to know next is: How do we cater to these identity types? Falk gives suggestions about how to serve each identity type in his book, but Philbrook wants to know more about personal guest experiences. For this reason, my initial survey will be altered to include a space for an email address to which Philbrook may send a 7-10 minute survey to guests. The survey will ask something to the effect of:

“What surprised you about your visit to Philbrook?”

“What could Philbrook do to make your visits more meaningful or engaging?”

“What can Philbrook do to persuade you to visit again?”

Whether the answer is, “I’d like more seating in the galleries,” or, “I wish there had been more information beside the artwork,” this information will give Philbrook specific examples of what they can do to create a more personal, meaningful museum experience for guests and encourage them to keep visiting and enjoying the museum.

Over the next two weeks, I will begin a second round of guest interceptions. Many of these sessions will occur during Spring Break. After collating and analyzing this data, hopefully we will begin to see a more complete view of Philbrook’s visitor identities.

 

Affinity Mapping: My First Interpretive Plan Core Team Meeting

This week, I was able to attend a meeting at Philbrook that included me, the Bernsen Director of Education and Programs, the Museum Educator for Adult and Public Programs, the Chief Curator, the Director of Collections and Exhibitions, the Director of Communications, and the Garden Manager. A lot transpired during this meeting; some of

IMG_0085
A view of the gardens, facing North.

the information I gathered during the meeting was merely interesting to me and useful as experience, and other information directly relates to my part in assisting with the interpretive plan this spring.

What I considered to be interesting about this meeting is that it gave me an inside look at the effort behind creating a successful museum experience for visitors. Each museum is extremely unique, so many times what is studied by students in textbooks doesn’t always or often apply once they begin their museum careers. For example, some large museums may be able to afford or demand the constant employment of a Chief Curator, a Deputy Curator, several curators that specialize in each type of art in the museum’s collection, and even curatorial assistants. However, I found out that the Chief Curator at Philbrook also curates the American Art. I’m told that sometimes this is the case and sometimes it is not. Each museum varies greatly based on its size, budget, collections, etc.

I also found the meeting to be interesting because I got a look at how each department of the museum relies on the other and how complicated organizing projects actually is between departmental responsibilities, projects, and deadlines. Not only that, but each department is completely invested in the success of the other departments. During the meeting, we talked about updating the audio-guide system, which involves removing the old audio-guide logo from signage and re-branding the signage in the communications department, as well as removing old signage from the gardens and historical home. The extent to which each department collaborated and considered one another’s limitations and abilities was quite remarkable. I was impressed with the way that the departments worked together toward their goal to makeover the audio-guide experience for guests.

 

IMG_0061
A panorama of one of my favorite rooms at Philbrook.

 

The part of the meeting that had the most impact for me was the affinity mapping exercise completed by each member of the core planning team. Without speaking, the team members took strips of the actual interview responses I had taken from guests and arranged them on a giant cork board with tacks. As they worked and rearranged the strips of paper, themes emerged from the responses. Although many fit with John Falk’s audience identities, we found something unique to Philbrook in the responses.

A large number of guests expressed that their main motivation for visiting the museum was to engage in quality time with a loved one. While one might think that this is a response that might be exclusive to Falk’s identity of a recharger, the responses pointed to something different. Explorers, rechargers, experience-seekers, facilitators, and even professional/hobbyists all fall within this category at times. Philbrook, a historic mansion with beautiful gardens and a great art collection, serves as a backdrop for many that enhances their experiences while spending time with the people they love the most.

In my responses, I found that rechargers and explorers paired together well because neither one really cared about the trajectory of the visit as long as they could soak in the art or scenery, and these pairs were often visiting to spend time together. Facilitators also come to spend quality time with friends, out-of-town guests, or their children. Their main goal is to show off the museum or impart some sort of knowledge to their guest, but they also do this to build a relationship. Many of these visitors came often and told me that they had visited within the last month to six months.

Even first-time visitors came because it was recommended online but ultimately came to spend time exploring or relaxing with someone else. Some were taking weekend getaways or a day trip away from the metro area in OKC to spend time alone together in a new environment.

I think that this points to a slight deviation from Falk’s identities that doesn’t disprove his research but simply illustrates a part of Philbrook’s unique atmosphere as a part of the Tulsa community.

This will be important for the interpretive plan because if its possible to measure how many visitors come with their own audience identities but with the underlying goal to spend quality time with their families and friends, then it may point to measures the museum can take toward making the galleries and grounds more accessible to groups like this. Engaging these folks could be as simple as adding more seating in the galleries for engaging conversation or developing motivation-focused pamphlets that guide guests around the museum based on their main reason for visiting.

Many suggestions for email surveys with incentives, new survey questions, and other methods of gathering information from guests were offered by the staff in the core planning team. There may also be an opportunity to speak to guests at the downtown Philbrook location as well.

I’m looking forward to seeing how this preliminary information will steer the project from this point forward.

Visitor Identity Data: Second Saturday and Valentine’s Day

I have been able to survey nearly forty people over the course of the past week. Some share more than others, though some take the initiative to answer, elaborate, and then interview me right back! I am learning that museum-goers are a special kind of people. Although they visit for multiple reasons, like exploring, seeking new experiences, relaxing, learning, or facilitating, museum-goers are seeking a deeper experience than that of paying to see a movie or going to an amusement park. Guests are looking to be amused, but they are also looking for a fulfilling leisure experience.

A few respondents do say that they just wanted to come to the museum because it was something to do, but most have specific reasons for visiting that they share with me by identifying what it is they enjoy most about their visits and what they remember the most.

I’m not yet finished with my preliminary round of guest interceptions, but so far I’ve been able to glean responses that really reflect the identity of the guests and define what exactly Philbrook Museum of Art means to Tulsans and to those traveling to Tulsa. I expected to talk with a lot of repeat visitors, and I have, but I also have learned that Philbrook has a glowing online reputation and that many guests take those recommendations seriously.

While researching ways to create a visual representation of what I’ve learned so far while talking to Philbrook guests, I found a free online tool called Word Cloud. This tool allows you to copy and paste data into a text box and then it generates a cloud of words that arrange themselves according to the frequency of that word in the data. Check it out:

wordcloud.jpg

Of course, many visitors remember the gardens, the art, a specific exhibit, the holidays, and they associate the museum with Tulsa or visiting Tulsa. We also see words like “together,” “husband,” or “children.” Folks associate Philbrook with spending quality time with their loved ones. The gardens are well-remembered for most, and why wouldn’t they be?

image1
Guests enjoy Valentine’s Day 2016 in Philbrook’s gardens.

Visitors make Philbrook a part of their lives. They come to the museum to experience a beautiful backdrop and atmosphere for making memories and meaning with their family, friends, and significant others.

One couple I stopped on Valentine’s Day visit often because they love art, but they were on a date to eat a Valentine brunch in the restaurant and reminisce. He had proposed to her, now his wife, at Philbrook just a few years before.

A group of folks I spoke with brought their daughter, an infant who could not yet walk, to start her MyMuseum box. The box is an interactive tool for children that is provided for free on Second Saturday with free admission. Each month, a tool for making art is added to the box and a prompt for a fun activity to do at home is provided. With the goal of making art a part of their child’s life, they visit each month to collect art supplies so that they will have plenty to choose from when their child is old enough to use them.

What I did not realize before beginning these guest interceptions is that I would become sentimental. This semester, I am also taking a course called Museums, Cultures, and Communities. In the course, we are learning about how important museums are to their communities and about the symbiotic relationship between museums and communities.

What I am realizing is that Philbrook has created such a foundation for community ownership in the museum that guests have made the museum a part of their families and memories. It’s really enlightening to realize what an impact Philbrook has made upon its community and to know that the programs and events at Philbrook do make a difference for many people.

Dipping a Toe in the Water: Guest Interceptions

Today, I spent some time at Philbrook walking through the galleries and speaking with guests about visiting the Museum. All of the visitors were amiable and accommodating, which was a relief to me. I learned a few interesting things as I interviewed guests.

IMG_0064
View from the main level to the gardens on the South side of Philbrook.

It was not a busy day today. The morning hours at Philbrook on Wednesdays are slow, according to one security guard, but there were several groups of third graders touring with docents who had endless patience and impressive engagement skills. I was able to conduct five interviews with guests milling through the three levels of galleries.

One woman came to bring her granddaughter who needed to see some art for a college class. She said that she never comes alone but always jumps at the opportunity to go. She loves the architecture most and she gets the bonus of spending time with her loved ones.

A man who I first sighted snapping a “selfie” with an Andy Warhol exhibit is an artist who came to admire the Wyeths exhibit in the upper level rotunda. He came to see the whole gallery but really focused on how much he enjoys learning about the techniques in the Wyeth exhibit with watercolors and dry-brush. This man is a great example of a visitor with a professional/hobbyist identity who perhaps switched roles to an explorer identity just briefly.

Another woman came with her two daughters, who attend a local university, while she is visiting them in Tulsa. She had previously come to the museum for a getaway with her husband, but she wanted her girls to learn to appreciate the time and effort it took to make the art and to gain awareness by viewing the galleries.

Yet another woman was visiting because she was studying for her docent review, but she visits the museum often. She brings her daughter and grandchildren to every Second Saturday when museum admission is free. She recalls that her favorite part about visiting with them is seeing their enthusiasm. She falls within the category of the facilitator identity, but today she was on a mission of her own.

A couple I spoke with both had identical identities as rechargers. They were visiting the museum because it was the only day they both had off work before Valentine’s Day, so Philbrook was a destination for relaxation. They especially enjoyed the grounds, and they visit at least twice a year.

I am eager to see what the rest of my guest intercepts reveal about visitor identity at Philbrook. The Museum has a unique role in Tulsa and a unique history, and I have a speculation that the visitor identities of Philbrook audiences will be unique as well.

John H. Falk and Museum Visitor Identities

The work for this museum project is based on the research of John H. Falk, who has done extensive research in the museum field about audience identity and how that identity impacts the museum visitor experience. This particular book is full of interviews from the California Science Center, but Falk is the kind of professional that finds opportunities to use his expertise in daily life as he experiences museums himself or while visiting with family.

We hope to use this research model to gain a better understanding of those who visit Philbrook Museum of Art. Rather than focusing on demographics, which Falk explains are actually rarely indicative of museum behavior in museums, we must focus on the core identity of each visitor to understand how visitors will behave and how we can effective engage our audiences. The goal is to offer exactly what our visitors need by identifying what is fulfilling or rewarding to them.

IMG_3117

John Falk describes a few different types of identities that describe most museum visitors. Many visitors identify strongly with one identity group, but some identify with a few or all of the identity groups as well.

Explorer Identity: The explorer identity would probably describe himself as curious, inquisitive, or as a lifelong learner. He looks for anything that piques his interest in an exhibit. He may linger ten minutes in front of one painting but pass up other artifacts that don’t appeal to his interests. It’s easy to switch identity roles from a professional/hobbyist identity or a facilitator identity to an explorer if you’re curious.

Professional/Hobbyist Identity: The professional/hobbyist is exactly that. She has already gained knowledge about the content of the exhibit. She may be looking to learn something new about an artist she favors, or she may be looking at Impressionist paintings for new techniques to try in her studio. Maybe she’s a museum professional looking for lighting ideas or a hobbyist photographer looking for new angles. This type of museum visitor might head directly to that which she has already seen but wants to review or that which she knows will help her to refine her skills.

Experience-seeker Identity: The experience-seeker likely came to see the most famous artifact in the museum, and anything else he sees is interesting but not the main goal of the visit. Experience-seekers are usually tourists or one-time visitors. Experience seekers may also be traveling bloggers or social media-lovers, checking monuments and artifacts off of their to-see list. They take a photo, post, and move on. Any other information or viewing takes a back-seat to their main reason for visiting the museum.

Facilitator Identity: The facilitator is often someone showing his parents around while they’re in town or a self-proclaimed “good father” attempting to educate his children while they also remain entertained. The facilitator is focused mostly on how his guests are enjoying the museum visit and how well they are retaining information. These visitors often describe their satisfaction with their visit by how well their guests enjoyed the visit. Facilitators will hang back and allow the guests to wander with curiosity and ask questions to check for comprehension and engagement.

Recharger Identity: The recharger visits the museum to relax and get away from her hectic lifestyle. For the recharger, it’s not as much about what she sees as how she feels. If the museum visit was satisfying in that she felt relaxed and invigorated when she left, then her museum visit was successful and rewarding. She may stroll slowly through the galleries and gardens, taking time to look, but many times superficially. She is there to recharge her batteries. If she learns from her visit, it is a happy coincidence.

Soon, I will begin a preliminary phase of intercepting guests for information that will help us to get a general idea of which identity types visit our museum and when. I have drafted a generalized survey including the location of the interception, the time of day, the date, and the social makeup of the group I’m interviewing. I will ask:

-Have you visited Philbrook before? If so, when?

-What do you remember most about your last visit?

-Why are you visiting today?

-What about those things appeal to you?

 

I am excited to jump right in and get started! Let’s see what our guest interceptions reveal to us about visitor identities at Philbrook Museum of Art!

Museum Project: Philbrook Museum of Art

downloadThis blog will document and describe the processes, meetings, and activities leading up to, during, and at the completion of my Museum Project.

The Museum Project is a 3 credit hour class that requires students to network by reaching out to local museums, to gain experience by working with museum staff, and to report back to a faculty member on their progress.

When I learned that I needed to complete a project to graduate with my M.A. in Museum Studies, my very first thought was that I wanted to complete this project at Philbrook Museum of Art in Tulsa, Oklahoma. The museum is deeply important to Tulsans. The grounds and gardens were donated by a prominent, wealthy, generous Tulsan who wanted to bring the arts to Tulsa communities. Not only is the estate beautiful, but the staff are heavily involved in the community, offering programs like Third Thursday and Second Saturday, as well as Movies on the Lawn and other holiday programs that open up the galleries and gardens to the public for free.

I first began communicating with Philbrook when I attended an informational session about becoming a docent at the museum, but that kind of training was not going to fit into my full time work and full class schedule. However, when I contacted the Bernsen Director of Education and Public Programs, I was greeted enthusiastically. Over the next few months, I will be working with the interpretive planning team to identify ways that the museum can engage audiences and improve visitor experiences. I will work with the Bernsen Director of Education and Public Programs, the Museum Educator for Adult and Public Programs, the Chief Curator, the Director of Collections and Exhibitions, the Director of Communications, and the Garden Manager.

I am excited to begin working with the museum as a student volunteer on an interpretive plan based on John H. Falk’s research on museum audience identities and motivations. I’m beginning this work by conducting research about Falk and looking for case studies or other reported information about audience identity and motivation at other museums. Using his work as a frame for learning more about the museum’s visitors, we will draw up a survey instrument and intercept guests to learn more about why visitors come to the museum.

We decided that starting a blog to record my experiences while working on this project would serve as a way for me to remember the process when it’s time to write my report, to document the processes used for my future research or for the museum’s benefit, and to use as a reflective tool.

From this point on, I will be meeting weekly with the Bernsen Director of Education and Public Programs and the Museum Educator of Adult and Public Programs to touch base and to set up a timeline for the project. Currently, I am doing a lot of research around audience motivation, identity, and John H. Falk. Monthly, I am being invited to join in the interpretive planning core team meetings.

I am endlessly grateful for this opportunity to learn, to gain experience, and to observe the professional museum world that bustles behind the scenes to create the wonderful museum experience to which I have grown accustomed at Philbrook throughout my life as a student and a lifelong learner.

As I’ve told my supervisors for this project, I’m a real Hermione, so let’s get to work!